The Request for Proposal (RFP) evaluation process is a critical step for many nonprofit organizations seeking investment advisory services. This process aims to sift through the array of proposals from various advisory firms to identify those that align best with your nonprofit's specific needs, emphasizing the experience, approach, focus, and fee structure that match your organization's criteria. Typically, the goal is to narrow the selection to approximately 2-4 firms that stand out due to their compatibility with your requirements.

Streamlining the Proposal Review Process

The initial phase of the review involves carefully examining all submitted proposals to ensure they meet basic criteria, such as being completed in full and submitted on time. Proposals that fail to meet these basic RFP evaluation criteria should be set aside. This step ensures that the review process focuses only on serious candidates who have shown a basic level of diligence and attention to detail.

Implementing an Evaluation Scorecard

Given the diversity in the responses' format, detail, and tone, introducing a standardized scoring system can streamline the evaluation process. A scorecard enables a uniform review of all proposals based on predetermined criteria that reflect your organization's priorities.

This approach facilitates a more structured evaluation and allows for an easy comparison of scores across different proposals. By aggregating scores, the committee can discern average ratings, highlighting the proposals that merit further consideration. This systematic assessment aids in narrowing down the choices to those most suitable for in-depth interviews and, eventually, selection.

Leveraging eCIO’s RFP Evaluation Scorecard

To support nonprofits in this endeavor, eCIO offers an RFP Evaluation Scorecard that can be used as an RFP evaluation template designed to complement our RFP Template for Nonprofit Organizations. Recognizing each nonprofit's unique nature and varying priorities, this scorecard is adaptable, allowing for adjustments in the weighting of each criterion to suit your organization's specific objectives.

While the scorecard is instrumental in streamlining the review process, it is essential to remember that it serves as a guide rather than a definitive answer to which advisory firm to hire. The scoring should be integrated into a broader decision-making framework considering qualitative factors and the organization's long-term goals. Complete the form below to receive a copy.

‍

‍