Introduction

Welcome to “The Ultimate Guide to Endowment Investments for Nonprofits,” your comprehensive resource for navigating the complexities of managing and optimizing financial assets for endowments and foundations. This guide is crafted for staff members, board members, and investment committees who seek to understand the principles of endowment investing and fulfill their fiduciary duties effectively. By following the insights and strategies outlined here, you can maximize your financial resources to support your organization’s mission sustainably and ethically.

Drawing from decades of experience in endowment and foundation asset management, this article covers crucial aspects such as governance, creating a robust Investment Policy Statement (IPS), setting sustainable spending rates, maintaining transparency with donors, and selecting the right investment advisor. Explore the best practices and strategies that will empower your organization to achieve long-term financial stability and mission fulfillment through prudent endowment investments.

I. Endowments 101

The Basics of Endowments

Fundamentals of an Endowment

An endowment is a pool of funds invested to generate ongoing income for your organization. The principal amount generally remains intact, while only the investment income or appreciation is used for the organization's activities, ensuring long-term financial stability. Proper endowment management involves a clear understanding of the structure and a commitment to preserving the principal. Effective endowment investments are key to maintaining this balance and supporting the organization’s goals.

Setting a Spending Rate

Establishing a sustainable spending rate is critical to ensuring that the endowment can support the organization perpetually. A typical spending rate ranges from 4% to 5% of the endowment’s average market value, designed to balance annual income needs with long-term growth. For example, if your endowment has an average growth rate of 7%, setting a 4% spending rate allows the principal to grow by 3%, helping to offset inflation and future needs. Strategically planned endowment investments are essential to achieve these targets.

Understanding the Differences Between Unrestricted and Restricted Endowment Assets

Unrestricted and restricted endowment assets differ primarily in their use flexibility and donor-imposed conditions. Unrestricted endowment assets can be allocated where most needed, supporting operational costs, program development, or strategic initiatives, and are typically spent at the discretion of the organization’s Board. This flexibility is crucial for addressing unforeseen challenges and opportunities. In contrast, restricted endowment assets come with specific donor instructions, often earmarked for particular programs or purposes, ensuring donor intent is honored but limiting the organization’s ability to respond to changing needs. Effective management requires careful accounting of restricted asset use to ensure compliance with donor specifications. Nonprofits may also set criteria for accepting restricted donations to balance the administrative burden and financial benefits, such as a minimum donation amount. Understanding the balance between these asset types is essential for effective endowment management and long-term financial planning.

II. Funding an Endowment

Initial Funding

A nonprofit endowment can be initially funded through various means, such as allocating excess cash reserves or receiving an unrestricted gift that enables the organization to establish a perpetual fund to support the organization. Excess cash reserves, often accumulated through prudent financial management, can be strategically invested to create a steady income stream for the organization and provide clarity and stability to support future initiatives. An unrestricted gift, typically provided by a generous donor without specific conditions, may be entirely or partially used to get an endowment off the ground and promoted to future donors. Establishing a perpetual fund is guided by assessing the organization's long-term financial stability and growth needs. Such a fund ensures that the nonprofit can sustainably maintain its mission-driven activities and services, providing financial security and fostering donor confidence.

Sources of Ongoing Endowment Funding

Today's $1 donation to an endowment may multiply in impact through prudent investment and growth, significantly enhancing its long-term value. Donations from donors can ensure a steady flow of contributions to support the organization’s long-term mission through their endowment. There are numerous strategies to solicit donor funding for an endowment, including:

• Planned Giving: Encourage donors to include the nonprofit in their estate plans through wills or life insurance policies, providing a reliable future funding source.
• Legacy Giving: Promoting bequests or charitable trusts, allowing donors to leave a lasting impact and create a meaningful legacy.
• Accepting Appreciated Stock: Enabling donors to give in a highly tax-efficient way, avoiding capital gains taxes while also benefiting from the charitable deduction.
• Qualified Charitable Distributions (QCDs): Donors over 70½ years old can directly make tax-advantaged gifts from their IRAs to the endowment.
• Donor-Advised Funds (DAFs): Donors can recommend grants from their DAFs, a growing method for individuals to support charities.
• Matching Gift Programs: Donors can maximize their donations by leveraging their employer's matching gift programs.
• General Fundraising: Promote the perpetual impact of donations through annual campaigns and major gift initiatives.

By leveraging these diverse funding avenues, nonprofits can build robust endowments that ensure financial stability and support their mission for future generations.

III. The Pillars of Endowment Investment Governance

Strong governance is a vital foundation for the organization’s investment program. It involves establishing robust frameworks and protocols to support board and staff turnover, ensuring continuity and stability in decision-making processes. Effective governance mechanisms provide clear lines of authority, foster accountability, and uphold fiduciary responsibilities. By implementing sound governance practices, nonprofits can mitigate risks, safeguard assets, and demonstrate a commitment to responsible stewardship of their endowment investments.

Your Board’s Fiduciary Duties

Board members have a fiduciary obligation to manage the endowment's assets and ensure the organization’s interests are placed ahead of their own. This includes preventing conflicts of interest, establishing a solid investment oversight group, implementing and maintaining appropriate documents and endowment investment policies, and conducting thorough due diligence to ensure financial resources are used effectively and ethically.

Effective Decision-Making with an Investment Committee

While the board has a fiduciary responsibility for your endowment, investment oversight is often delegated to an investment committee. The investment committee aids the board in fulfilling its fiduciary duties by ensuring efficient, transparent asset management and decision-making aligned with the organization’s best interests. The committee typically works with the investment advisor partner and oversees the performance of the assets. A well-defined Committee Charter outlines the committee's authority, roles, and responsibilities, ensuring efficient and transparent decision-making. Typically, the committee comprises 3-7 qualified members who meet quarterly to review policies, performance, and compliance and provide reports to the board. This structure supports the effective management of endowment investments.

Critical Endowment Investment Policy Documents

Investment-related policy documents provide consistency and continuity, especially during staff or board transitions. They document decision-making processes, build stakeholder trust, and ensure that strategic decisions align with long-term goals and the organization's mission.

The Investment Policy Statement (IPS)

The Investment Policy Statement (IPS) is the cornerstone of your investment program. It guides the organization toward its goals while ensuring adherence to fiduciary responsibilities. The IPS should clearly define duties and responsibilities, outline strategic asset allocation, and establish criteria for performance evaluation and spending policies.

Other Important Policies

• Conflict of Interest Policy: The Conflict of Interest Policy manages personal conflicts of interest among leaders, protecting the organization’s reputation and legal standing.
• Spending Policy: A Spending Policy governs distributions from the endowment, sets spending rates, and defines qualified expenditures.
• Gifting Policy: Gifting Policies ensure gifts are used according to donor intentions and align with the organization's mission.

IV. Developing an Investment Strategy for Your Endowment

A solid investment strategy ensures an endowment's long-term sustainability and purpose. A successful investment strategy focuses on solutions tailored to the organization's short- and long-term needs and objectives, aligning with its mission, financial goals, and risk tolerance. This involves developing strategies that support the endowment's purpose, conducting a thorough analysis, making prudent decisions, and providing ongoing monitoring to optimize returns while preserving capital. By diversifying investment portfolios and adapting strategies to changing market conditions, nonprofits can enhance their financial resilience and ensure sustainable growth for the future.

Key Investment Principles for Endowments

Perpetual Principal Preservation: An endowment is typically set up with the intent that the principal amount remains indefinitely intact. By utilizing only the appreciation of the principal for the organization's activities, the endowment ensures consistent financial support and perpetually furthers the organization's mission.

Transparency: Maintaining transparency in investment strategies and decisions is essential for building trust and accountability. It allows stakeholders to understand how funds are managed and ensures alignment with the organization's values and goals.

Strategic Asset Allocation: Implementing strategic asset allocation is vital for balancing spending and growth, ensuring the endowment can keep pace with inflation. This approach helps achieve long-term financial stability and supports the organization's mission over time.

Low Costs: Minimizing investment costs is crucial for maximizing net returns. By keeping expenses low, more funds can be allocated to the endowment's objectives, enhancing overall financial performance.

Effective Performance Measurement: Regular and effective performance measurement is necessary to evaluate the success of the investment strategy. It provides insights into how well the endowment achieves its financial goals and allows timely adjustments to improve outcomes.

Consideration of ESG: Integrating Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) factors into investment decisions can align the endowment with clear mission-based values, making sense for organizations with defined ethical standards. However, there are risks to an ESG strategy, including potential difficulties in achieving consensus and the challenge of balancing diverse stakeholder perspectives.

V. The Role of an Investment Advisor Financial Consultant or Advisor for Endowments

The Value of Endowment Investment Advisors

Experienced investment advisors bring valuable expertise and guidance to foundations and endowments, helping them navigate investment challenges and ensure adequate financial asset management. Here are key areas where an advisor can bring significant value to your organization:

• Alignment of Stakeholders: Investment advisors are essential in facilitating consensus-building and ensuring everyone works towards a common objective, enhancing decision-making efficiency.
• Optimal Asset Allocation Decisions: They guide endowments in making effective asset allocation decisions for long-term returns.
• Crafting Essential Documents: Advisors assist in creating critical documents like the Investment Policy Statement for structured decision-making.
• Independent and Objective Investment Management: They offer unbiased advice to mitigate emotional biases in investment decisions.
• Optimizing Balance Sheet and Fund Management: They bring expertise in optimizing balance sheets and managing funds for increased asset growth.
• Understanding Investment Results: They clarify financial data and reports, aiding informed investment decision-making.
• Disciplined Rebalancing: Advisors implement rebalancing strategies to maintain desired asset allocation and reduce risk.
• Facilitating Transitions: They ensure smooth transitions in investment committees and board memberships for continuity.
• Cost-Effectiveness: Investment advisors reduce overall investment expenses by strategically selecting low-cost asset managers.
• Building Confidence in the Investment Program: Their presence boosts confidence in the oversight group and donors, ensuring commitment to financial objectives.
• Donor Support: They offer resources to help drive donor engagement and facilitate contributions.

Advisor Communication is Essential to Success

Effective communication with your investment advisor is critical to achieving your goals as a stakeholder in an endowment or foundation. You should receive frequent and transparent communication to ensure that everyone involved in your endowment's governance – including your staff, investment oversight committee, and the board – is fully informed and engaged in the investment process. This inclusive approach ensures informed decision-making, fosters collective responsibility, and upholds transparency and trust. A high level of engagement is essential for the success of your endowment investments.

Expect at least quarterly updates from your advisor and more often during significant market or organizational changes. These updates should inform you about portfolio performance, investment strategy, market trends, and how they align with your endowment's goals.

Your reports should be clear, concise, and without complex jargon, allowing stakeholders of varying financial expertise to understand them. Communication shouldn't be restricted to one-on-one interactions; it should encompass all stakeholders, including staff, committees, and the board.

To evaluate if your investment advisor is communicating effectively, consider these five questions:

• Performance Reporting: Are the performance reports straightforward, and do they include relevant benchmark comparisons?
• Accessibility: Are communication and reporting available online in an organized, easily accessible manner?
• Archiving: Are past reports and communications archived systematically for reference?

• Policy Review: Does the advisor regularly communicate about policy reviews and updates?
• Custom Reviews: Can custom portfolio and performance reviews be shared using video to provide a more engaging and detailed analysis?

These questions will help you assess the quality and effectiveness of your investment advisor's communication, ensuring it aligns with the needs of your endowment or foundation.

Choosing the Right Investment Advisor for Your Endowment

Typical Financial Advisor vs. Endowment Investment Advisor

While most financial advisors focus on individual wealth and retirement needs, endowment investment advisors are attuned to endowments and foundations' distinct long-term goals and compliance requirements. Compared to typical advisors, who may lack more expertise in specialized areas crucial for endowment governance, specialist advisors are adept at managing the unique needs of entities like endowments and foundations. They tailor their processes to align with your organization's objectives, enhancing decision-making and overall success. The typical advisors' service model often leads to communication gaps and misaligned goals within endowments. Your organization will be best served by an advisor who engages a wide range of stakeholders - staff, committees, boards, and donors - ensuring that everyone is well-informed and confident in the stewardship of your assets.

Learn more about how an endowment investment advisor adds value to your organization by downloading “The Value of a Nonprofit Investment Advisor.”

How to Select Your Investment Advisor

Selecting an investment advisor is a pivotal decision for your board and investment oversight committee regarding investment and endowment management. Given the significant implications for your organization's financial future, this choice demands a careful and well-structured approach. There are several pathways to consider in this selection process, each with unique advantages and considerations.

• Investment Management Request for Proposal (RFP): An RFP is a formal document that invites investment consultants and advisors to submit proposals outlining their services, qualifications, and fees. This approach allows your organization to compare various options in a structured format. However, it's essential to recognize the intricacies and time commitments associated with the RFP process. Crafting a detailed RFP, reviewing submissions, and conducting follow-ups can be extensive and complex.
• Targeted Selection: Alternatively, some organizations prefer a targeted selection of a few advisory firms. This approach involves shortlisting two or three highly qualified firms and conducting in-depth interviews. This method can be more efficient than the RFP process. It allows for a more dynamic and interactive discussion, helping you assess each firm's compatibility with your organization more directly. Such face-to-face or virtual meetings facilitate a deeper understanding of each firm's approach, values, and how they might align with your organization's goals.

For a series of papers and resources to help your organization determine if an RFP is suitable for you and how to go about the process, see these links:

• Should You Issue an RFP to Select Your Next Investment Advisor?
• 5 Pitfalls to Avoid When Issuing an Investment Advisor RFP
• The Alternative to an RFP: A Simplified Approach to Selecting Your Investment Advisor
• How to Create an Investment Management RFP for Endowment Organizations with RFP Template
• How to Evaluate an Investment Advisor's RFP

VI. Conclusion

Effective investment management, governance, and communication are vital to growing your endowment, inspiring donors, and fulfilling your long-term mission. We encourage you to explore eCIO's extensive investment resources for endowments to understand better investment and governance best practices in the nonprofit sector. These resources are designed to guide and support your organization's journey toward financial sustainability and alignment with its mission.

Introduction to Our Endowment Investment Advisor Team

To assist you in understanding your endowment’s investment options, we offer a mutual introduction with a member of our dedicated endowment investment advisor team. Our advisors are well-versed in addressing specific needs and challenges of endowments and foundations. They can answer any questions and provide personalized assistance to help your organization navigate its unique financial landscape. This introduction allows your organization to benefit from expert advice and tailored support in your investment and governance endeavors.

‍

‍